Why virtualization

Virtualization makes it possible to run several virtual servers on one physical server. Instead of a separate server for each system, Active Directory, a file server, accounting and a dedicated application all run as virtual machines (VMs) on the same hardware, each isolated from the others.

The advantages are well known: less hardware to maintain, better use of resources (consolidation), and the ability to add a new server without buying a device. The most important advantage for a business is usually flexibility on the day of a fault. A virtual machine is ultimately a set of files, so it is relatively easy to back it up in full, move it to another server and restore it. When each physical server runs a single system, a hardware fault means replacement, reinstallation and restore. In a well-organized virtual environment, the same fault is handled by moving the machines to another server.

Three platforms are especially common in businesses: Microsoft Hyper-V, VMware and Proxmox VE. All of them are used in production environments, and the differences between them mostly concern licensing, management tools and fit with the existing environment.

Hyper-V

Hyper-V is Microsoft’s virtualization platform, and it is part of Windows Server. For businesses that already work in a Windows environment, with Active Directory and Windows servers, it is a natural choice: the tools are familiar, management integrates with the rest of the environment, and there is support for clusters (failover cluster) and for moving running machines between servers (live migration).

An important point is licensing. Hyper-V itself is included, but every virtual machine that runs Windows Server needs appropriate licensing, and the Windows Server edition you choose (Standard / Datacenter) affects how many such machines you can run on the same server. Planning licensing correctly in advance saves surprises, especially when adding servers or moving to a cluster.

VMware

VMware vSphere, which includes ESXi and vCenter, was for years the default in many organizations. It is known for advanced management capabilities, broad support from hardware and backup software vendors, and a large ecosystem of complementary tools.

Since the company was acquired by Broadcom, the licensing model has changed: the move is to subscriptions and bundles, and perpetual licenses are no longer sold. For some businesses this change makes the environment more expensive, so many organizations are reconsidering their choice, especially when a renewal date or hardware replacement comes up. A business that already works with VMware does not have to move, but it should check what this means before the next renewal, and understand how much time and work a move would require if one is decided on.

Proxmox VE

Proxmox VE is an open source platform based on Linux and KVM technology, and it can run both virtual machines and lightweight containers (LXC). Management is done through a web interface, and there is support for clusters, high availability and shared storage, including Ceph.

The software itself is available with no licensing cost, and the company that develops it offers a paid subscription that includes a stable update repository (enterprise repository) and support. For production environments the subscription is worth considering, and in any case make sure there is someone who knows the platform in depth. Proxmox is especially suitable for those who want to reduce dependence on a single vendor’s licensing, provided it comes with professional management. Without such management, the savings on licensing may show up as longer downtime on the day of a fault.

How to compare: the important questions

  • What the existing environment is: which operating systems run, and which tools whoever manages IT already knows.
  • Licensing over time: the cost is measured over several years (TCO), including licensing of the operating systems inside the machines.
  • Availability (high availability): whether the business needs a cluster of several servers, so a server that goes down does not stop work, or whether one server with a good backup and a recovery plan (DRP) is enough.
  • Backup: whether the backup software in use supports the platform, and at what level.
  • Support: who answers when there is a deep fault, the vendor, a reseller or the IT company.
  • Specialized software: some software vendors define supported platforms. Check before you decide.

There is no single platform that is “the best.” There is a platform that suits a particular business, its budget and whoever will manage it.

What moving between platforms involves

Businesses considering a move, mainly away from VMware, usually ask how complicated it is. The answer depends on the environment. Moving a virtual machine between platforms is a known process, and there are tools that help with it, but every machine needs checking: drivers, network settings, software licensing tied to hardware, and compatibility of the backup software.

The safe way is to plan the move in advance: mapping all the machines and the dependencies between them, a trial on less critical machines (pilot), a full and tested backup before each stage, and a defined maintenance window with a rollback plan if something does not work. A move made under pressure, for example a few days before a license expires, is where things go wrong.

Security and backup for a virtual environment

The concentration that makes virtualization efficient also makes it a point of risk. Whoever gains control of the virtualization layer (the hypervisor) controls all the servers running on it. In recent years ransomware groups have explicitly targeted virtualization servers, because a single encryption there takes down the whole organization at once.

  • The virtualization management interfaces sit on a separate management network, and are not reachable from workstations.
  • Administrator accounts are protected with MFA, and are separate from day-to-day accounts.
  • The platform is updated on an ongoing basis, including the servers’ firmware.
  • The backup is stored outside the virtual environment and out of reach of the regular administrator accounts, with a copy that cannot be changed or deleted (immutable backup).

It is also worth limiting who may create, delete and restore machines (RBAC). A single destructive action, by mistake or on purpose, can delete an entire server with all the data on it.

Who manages the environment

A virtual environment is the heart of the business’s IT. When it is managed well, a fault in a physical server is a managed event: the machines move to another server or are restored from backup. When it is managed carelessly, the same fault can take the business down for days, and a security incident in it can expose all the information the business holds.

That is why the IT company that plans and manages the environment needs to combine knowledge of the platform with knowledge of information security: network separation (segmentation), permission management, protected backup and restore tests. It also needs to know what the data security regulations and the National Cyber Directorate guidance require from servers that hold personal information. The choice of platform matters, and the quality of its management matters more.

Summary

  • Hyper-V is especially suited to existing Windows environments, with correct planning of Windows Server licensing.
  • VMware offers broad management capabilities, and the new licensing model justifies a review before every renewal.
  • Proxmox VE reduces licensing dependence, and requires professional management that knows it.
  • A move between platforms is planned in advance, with a tested backup and a rollback plan.
  • On any platform: a separate management network, MFA, ongoing updates and an isolated backup (immutable backup) that is tested by restoring from it.